First off- How cute, yet sad is the cover of this book? Although it seemed like a sad little book, I thought it was important to read. Children can really struggle with moving from one place to another. We see this more frequently now because of military families and with today's economy, parents have to move for job opportunities or to follow their current job. It is yet another difficult time in a child's life that Nancy Carlson makes a bit easier. Nancy Carlson's illustrations, as always, are so wonderful. She shows the two girls playing in the sand in the summer, making snowmen in the winter and then really expresses the sadness when one of the girls moves away. Some of Carlson's books are short but that's what makes children really read them on their own and not always have to be read aloud. I like that she gets the message across without using too many words that would deter a new reader from her stories. I know as a child I would flip through a book and look at how long it was, and how pretty the pictures were. I have no doubt that I would have loved these books as a kid. Carlson lets the reader know that it is okay if a friend moves away, it doesn't mean your friendship is over. The girls can still stay in touch and their are plenty of opportunities to make new friends.
One question I would like to address for this text is:
Whose voices are typically portrayed in this author’s work? Whose voices are missing or less central?
Typically, the voices portrayed in the authors's work are young students. She doesn't always include adults in the book. In some of her books, there are family members and teachers but majority of the stories are written from the child's point of view. This is one of the many reasons I enjoy Nancy Carlson's work. They are not "preachy" Children seem to understand messages better when they find them on their own in the book, not when it is told to them. Like the first book I discovered from this author on my partners blog, How to Clean Your Room, she makes the book very funny to readers of any age, but still gets the book's message across. Instead of saying things like "you should clean your room like this.." or "clean your room the first time your mother tells you", she lets the reader know that is what they should do, but doesn't order them to do it- What fun would that be??